Democrats, Debt, and AI – American Enterprise Institute – AEI
Democrats across America have concluded, not unreasonably, that voters’ unease about artificial intelligence and data centers helped them in last week’s midterm elections—and might again in two years. Dreams of the Washington trifecta abound.
But what to do between now and then? That’s far less clear. This from the Politico piece “Democrats see a winning 2028 message in voters’ tech unease”:
For some Democrats, the answer is a direct confrontation with the tech industry. Progressive lawmakers and activists have called for a pause on advanced AI development, congressional testimony from major lab executives and a ban on superintelligence — AI systems that theoretically could one day surpass human cognitive capabilities. … Others, particularly more centrist Democrats, are wary of making opposition to the technology itself the centerpiece of their message. They want to emphasize worker protections, consumer safeguards and public oversight while arguing that AI can still deliver economic benefits.
Whatever their consultants and pollsters tell them, Democrats at all levels should think hard about the political risks of policies that might delay or diminish the economic payoff from AI.
Keep in mind that I am talking about something beyond the current impact of AI investment on economic growth (offset by imports of AI-related equipment), as seen in this Morgan Stanley chart:
Here’s the scenario I’m thinking about: Without a 1990s-style, technology-driven boom—or at least a boomlet—of markedly faster economic and productivity growth, the next president (betting markets reckon there is a two-in-three chance it will be a Democrat) might well have to jettison whatever agenda he or she campaigned on in favor of a grim regime of deficit reduction. And we’re not there yet (even as techie optimism about AI capabilities increases):
As it is, the fiscal numbers are pretty bad. This breakdown from Goldman Sachs suggests the US is one of the developed world’s most fiscally vulnerable countries:
Nor are things likely to improve much in the next two years. The Trump administration has shown little interest in fiscal rectitude, and Democrats barely mentioned it, if at all, during the midterms. Things might even get a bit worse—even assuming no recession—according to investment bank Piper Sandler (boldface by me):
Despite the large new majorities Democrats will enjoy next year, we think there is limited room to extract concessions from Republicans when reversing spending cuts and a natural limit to how much defense spending Democrats will accept. This dynamic keeps a natural lid on fiscal expansion next year. At the same time, policies that will continue to expand the deficit are more likely than policies to shrink it. The path of least resistance to a budget agreement is for both sides to spend more and it is highly unlikely Republicans will agree to offset any new spending increases with higher taxes.
The rise in US long-term interest rates this year may partly reflect investors seeking compensation for greater fiscal risk due to the flood of red ink, though not yet enough to rouse Washington. When that moment will come is anyone’s guess. The trouble with waiting for markets to deliver an unmistakable verdict is that by then the remedy, in higher taxes and lower spending, will be far more painful. Democratic dreams of universal child care, Medicare for All, or a grand infrastructure or clean-energy program would not survive the encounter.
Democrats have been here before, watching the need for budget austerity erase dreams of a New New Deal. Bill Clinton arrived in the White House intending to update Franklin Roosevelt’s liberalism for an impending new century, with his “Putting People First” agenda of public investment in infrastructure, worker training, education, and health care. Nervous bond investors, known as “bond vigilantes” back then, soon scuttled most of it. Clinton instead became, as he ruefully put it, an “Eisenhower Republican,” seeking faster growth through deficit reduction and lower interest rates.
Unlike Clinton, Barack Obama got his healthcare plan passed, but his broader ambitions were frustrated mostly. He, too, arrived in the White House hoping to remake America’s economy through public investment. The financial crisis forced him to put rescue first, while swelling deficits and political opposition constrained the size of his stimulus. By his second term, Washington’s fixation on the national debt helped produce spending caps and sequestration, and what fun in that.
In 2016, he told the New York Times that failing to launch “a massive infrastructure project” in 2012–14, when interest rates were low and the construction industry was still struggling, had been a costly mistake. “It was the perfect time to do it,” he lamented.
It’s not hard to imagine a three-peat of frustrated Democratic presidential ambitions. Folks on the left should be hoping for an AI economic tailwind—and the tax revenue it would generate—to at least lower the risk of needing to address a debt crisis.
For example: A Brookings study from last July finds that a “once-in-a-generation productivity shock”—on the higher end of most economists’ estimates, but not those of Silicon Valley, to be sure—could cut budget deficits by as much as 5 percentage points of GDP by 2036. Similarly, the Yale Budget Lab sees a productivity boost stabilizing the size of the national debt relative to GDP. Both have caveats, such as the cost of helping workers if unemployment rises, but you get the picture.
This would not negate the need for other fiscal action, but it would be a helpful start that politicians in both parties should try to enable or at least do no harm.
James Pethokoukis, Senior Fellow; DeWitt Wallace Chair; Editor, AEIdeas Blog
Commentary
Faster, Please!
A weekly summary of my various essays, Q&As, and podcasts. And along with it, a shorter version of the most notable Up-Wing and Down-Wing news items from the past week.
BY James Pethokoukis ON 7 Nov 26
Commentary
Faster, Please!
The US midterms suggest it isn’t something to be ignored
BY James Pethokoukis ON 4 Nov 26
Commentary
Faster, Please!
We need more sci-fi that shows the long road getting from here to there
BY James Pethokoukis ON 3 Nov 26
American Enterprise Institute
1789 Massachusetts Ave. NW
Washington, DC 20036
Main Telephone: 202.862.5800
© 2026 American Enterprise Institute | Privacy Policy